Sunday, March 22, 2009

Pandit the Bandit

I've received mixed responses on my Pandit post, especially vis-a-vis John Thain.

I want to emphasize that I am not saying John Thain is a great guy. In fact, like many banking CEO's, he might be on a different plane of the universe when it comes to his personal (not legal) values of right and wrong. All that I am saying is that he has done the best for his shareholders of the CEO's who have been in burning banks, far better than Cayne, Fuld, or now, Pandit, whose respective performance numbers are -100%, -100%, - 95%.

Thain, unlike all these other CEO's who were in a constant state of denial, saw the writing on the wall after he was brought in to fix Stan O'Neal's mess in late 2007 and he prevented Merrill Lynch from going bankrupt thereby preventing a total wipe out of whatever brand equity and human capital it had left, saving ML shareholders, creditors, and employees in the process. What other course of action should he have taken? He took the best one available for ML. His fiduciary responsibility was to his bondholders, shareholders, employees, and customers, ML's institutional strengths were in areas that BOFA has always been weak in, e.g. Bank of America has always wanted a real brokerage arm and a real commodities operation, and he knew that it was his best bet to save the firm.

Yes, Thain spent $1.2 MM to renovate his office, two conference rooms, and a reception area in December 2007, after he was named CEO of ML from his then current post running the NYSE. Of that $1.2MM, $800,000 went to the designer, and $400,000 for the contents. In hindsight, he said it was not a good thing to do, he apologized and reimbursed the firm for the expenses. It was clearly not the greatest idea in world. But better than flushing 95% of your firms value into the toilet.

Furthermore, recent events emphasize my previous post. Pandit just announced he is spending $10 MM renovating his office while his stock is on the McDonald's dollar menu. So my point stands. Thain has had the best performance of any of the banking CEO's whose house is on fire. Pandit needs to be fired as he obviously lacks even the most basic common sense and foresight. How about learning from Thain's mistake?

I have been so aghast and so appalled at the recent behavior of many captains of industry, that I am building a new website,, that will contain all the gory details on this incredibly callous, often illicit, and generally distasteful behavior. It will have an action reaction pair:

Golden Parachutes
Job Losses



Stay tuned, it should be interesting.

No comments: